Joey Graziadei Reproposes to Fiancée Kelsey Anderson Over Two Years After Their Initial Engagement

A Second Proposal for a New Chapter

Joey Graziadei and Kelsey Anderson are celebrating their love with a special second proposal. More than two years after Graziadei first proposed during the Season 28 finale of The Bachelor, the couple revealed they recently got engaged again in an intimate moment shared in Cabo San Lucas.

The announcement was made through a joint Instagram post, where Graziadei captioned, “SHE SAID YES (again) 💍.”

“Proposing again meant taking something that was already extraordinary and making it fully our own,” Graziadei shared. “It’s about reaffirming our promise and love to each other, just the two of us. Forever isn’t enough with you. I can’t wait to make you my wife.”

This renewed engagement comes as the couple continues planning their wedding set for 2027. Recently, Anderson, 28, shared details about their vision for the big day during an appearance on Brianna “Chickenfry” LaPaglia’s PlanBri Uncut podcast in April.

A Romantic Wedding Without Sponsorships

Despite their public profiles, Anderson emphasized that they want their wedding to focus on their relationship rather than sponsorships or brand deals.

“We decided, we were like, we don't want to do any brand deals for our wedding,” Anderson explained. “I’m not going to post about it or have someone sponsor our bar or anything like that. We want it to be seamless and about us.”

While they plan to have wedding content creators document the event, Anderson expressed her desire to stay present during the celebration. “But I’m not gonna be making TikToks,” she said. “They’ll do that so I can just be in the moment.”

The couple envisions a wedding that’s “romantic” and “moody,” perhaps featuring candles and a “garden party vibe” during cocktail hour. She also mentioned trying to keep things relaxed during the planning process.

“I’m not 100% set on anything,” Anderson admitted. “I think I’ll just go with the flow.”

“As long as he’s there, I’m there, and we’ve got a good DJ or band, I think I’ll be good,” she added.

They’ve already enlisted wedding planners Josiah Carr and Justin McGregor of SAMKOMA to help bring their vision to life. “They are two of the sweetest humans, and we’re so excited to work with them,” the planners shared in September. “We feel really fortunate to be part of their journey!”

From Reality TV Romance to Real-Life Partnership

Graziadei has also started building his wedding party. Earlier this year, he revealed that fellow Bachelor Nation alum Tanner Courtad will be his best man.

In March, Graziadei surprised Courtad with an engraved cup reading, “Will you be my best man?” Courtad’s reaction was disbelief before he enthusiastically said, “Let’s go!”

The couple first met during Graziadei’s season of The Bachelor, following his appearance on The Bachelorette. In the March 2024 finale of The Bachelor, Graziadei proposed to Anderson, officially ending the season with their engagement.

Since then, they’ve been open about adjusting to life as a public couple after keeping their relationship private during filming.

“We have a shared note where we both add things to it,” Anderson shared previously, talking about their simple plans—dance classes, pottery, grocery shopping—things they look forward to doing together.

During that period, they also attended couples therapy to strengthen their communication and navigate the unique challenges of their relationship amid the show's intense spotlight.

“It's not easy because we both value physical touch,” Graziadei said. “But couples counseling made a huge difference for us.”